After cancelling our trip to Australia, I started checking possible flights to use our Air New Zealand credit, during the time we already had planned for vacation.
Prices to New Zealand were higher than normal and going to Fiji, Samoa, or the Cook Islands cost more than I wanted to spend.
In the process of searching, I found that Southwest had a great deal on flights to Hawaii (less than $500/person), so we decided to go to the Big Island, since neither of us had been to that island before.
We were able to book the trip for March 10-18, so we didn't need to rearrange work or dog sitter schedules, other than losing a few days at the front end.
We also didn't need to alter our packing list much, since we were still going to have beach/snorkel days and time in the tropics/rainforest.
This is an overview of where we went each day:
Day 1: Travel and arrive in Kona
Day 2: Visit beaches on Kona Coast
Day 3: Chocolate tour and visit South Kohala area
Day 4: Drive along Kona coast area, across Ka'u (south), through Hawaii Volcanoes NP on way to Hilo
Day 5: Visit waterfalls and parks in Hilo area
Day 6: Visit the Puna region
Day 7: Drive along East coast / Hamakua region and north / Kohala region on way to Kona
Day 8: Visit beaches on South Kona coast.
Day 9: Travel home